If you're a veteran of Fallout 3, you'll be plenty familiar with a Wasteland order known as the Brotherhood of Steel. Going to wipe the slate clean. This act earned him an enormous amount of respect and loyalty from his chapter. Can you join the Brotherhood of Steel in Fallout New Vegas? BUT! I think it's a fairly valid point because by the time you've finished the quest line for the BOS not only are you one of their highest ranking members but you're also able to bring anyone you want into their bunker, including NCR such as Boone. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Since you talk to Senior Knight Lorenzo about the vents prior to reporting to McNamara, there's a window where you have an opportunity you aren't supposed to to still turn on him by talking to Hardin and this is what causes things to glitch out as the quest script does not actually lock the latter option out until you talk to McNamara after telling Lorenzo about fixing the vents. I'm doing the quest Still In The Dark and I'm almost done, but I was wondering, what are the advantages and disadvantages of either helping McNamara or helping Hildern to oust McNamara? ... To broker a truce, you must not have ousted Elder McNamara during the quest Still in the Dark. ... Hardin is a jackass and the quest to become an initiate with McNamara is easy as fuck. 1.0. 8 ST, 7 PE, 8 EN, 4 CH, 3 IN, 6 AG, 4 LK close. Brotherhood of steel in Fallout NV. The whole reason she wants to leave the BOS near the end of her companion quest is because of McNamara being so stubborn, so wouldn't she prefer Hardin's route of pretty much ending the lockdown right then and there? The Brotherhood of Steel orignally came into contact with the NCR back in 2259 following the outbreak of the NCR-Enclave War which broke out a year prior. Gore everywhere. 141. (/spoiler) If you want the brotherhood to live on and get the good ending let him stay. Conflict is inevitable, may as well crush the brotherhood before they have a chance to recover. After joining the BoS, Hardin addresses the courier as "brother" not outsider. Hardin is all about the mission to secure tech, while McNamara believes the parts about survival area more important right now. ... Lv 5. [The brotherhood eventually dies out!] close. The 3-day wait corresponds to the universal refresh time that also affects vendor inventories and non-player character respawns. If you're a veteran of Fallout 3, you'll be plenty familiar with a Wasteland order known as the Brotherhood of Steel. ... Hardin is a jackass and the quest to become an initiate with McNamara is easy as fuck. The Mojave Chapter of the Brotherhood of Steel, more commonly known as the Brotherhood Mojave Chapter, the Mojave Brotherhood, or the Mojave Chapter, is a chapter of the Brotherhood of Steel based in the Mojave Wasteland in the western reaches of the former United States. Preparing breadcrumbs… Search. Fallout: New Vegas overthrowing the brotherhood of steel elder question? McNamara is the one that started the lockdown of the BoS true, but he can be made to see the error of his ways with a lot of convincing (and Veronica). Additional info That’ll be handled shortly, but first… let’s finish up exploring the Hidden Valley Bunker. Once you reach this point, exit the entire bunker complex then re-enter the bunker and talk with McNamara again. When defeat became imminent, he followed the new acting elder, Nolan McNamara, in the retreat to the McCullough range and Hidden Valley. I was working with Mr. House most of the time in the main story line and I also joined the Brotherhood of Steel earlier. The fallacy involves making decisions by using quantitative observations and ignoring all other types of observation, as he does in the quest I Could Make You Care. So now that I am doing one, I've reached a bit of a dilemma. Overall, McNamara is the better choice for Fallout: New Vegas. Addendum: Please don't tell me to read Vault Wiki, I have, it's just not really clear about the positive and negative ramifications of both options. Human, Caucasian Ask Question Asked 4 years, 2 months ago. Fallout New Vegas Brotherhood of Steel? Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Unless you're talking about Hardin's second quest, which still isn't that hard, but is annoying if you want Power Armor … When dealing with the tribes, in the quest The House Always Wins V, Mr House will always refuse to negotiate, and want you to destroy the Brotherhood of Steel.The corresponding quest from Yes Man, however, Wild Card: Side Bets, gives you an option to ignore the Brotherhood.Like the same option with the other factions, this means giving up on getting their support for your plans. *Only if the Courier overthrows McNamara. ... Browse other questions tagged fallout-new-vegas or ask your own question. Gameplay on fallout new vegas when doing the quest for the republic part 2 u have to go and find brotherhood of steel and stuff but u can also do missions for them and i was reading in my stragety guide u could get brotherhood to side with ncr but ever time i talk to main brotherhood guy elder mcnamara … Fallout New Vegas Brotherhood of Steel? rank Fallout: New Vegas. Fallout New Vegas community and everything related. The easy way to determine if Hardin has taken control is when you first enter the bunker, check out Ramos. appearances Hidden Valley bunkerHELIOS One (formerly) ... Elder Hardin And NCR Alliance He still fears the NCR and believes they are still hunting the Brotherhood, when in fact the NCR is currently overburdened fighting wars on multiple fronts and is not even looking for the Brotherhood. Not surprisingly, siding with Hardin is going to bring the Brotherhood of Steel into your fold for the endgame as associated with the main quest known as Wild Card: Side Bets. He, under the appropriate circumstances, will even support the NCR. He is the diplomatic approach, and honestly, the one I tend to choose. NOTE: You may have to wait 3 days or so after exiting the bunker complex before re-entering will work. sex blow up Kimball and every single other person at the speech in just one shot. This allows you to spare the Brotherhood Of Steel during "The House Always Wins V", with a speech check of 80, and if you are at least "Accepted" with the Brotherhood Of Steel. Fallout: New Vegas Edit. Published: Jan 19, 2010. Ask Question Asked 4 years, 2 months ago. He seems to be a more flat Neutral kinda guy. They are located in the bunker (M13:1). He assumed command of the Mojave chapter, and the rank of elder, when Father Elijah vanished during the battle. But he feels like a majority of tech would be better safeguarded rather than being used. McNamara is honestly more levelheaded, and is willing to make some compromises to fight alongside the NCR at the battle, even if they have had some bad history with them. affiliation Most likely if you did keep McNamara in charge you'd be next in line to become Elder because of all the good you did for them. In contrast, Hardin is a conservative, dyed-in-the-wool Brotherhood member who believes in the ideals and mission of the Brotherhood without question. karma Brotherhood of Steel, Hardin and Peace with the NCR » Thu Dec 15, 2011 6:21 am I don't know whether this will ever be acknowledged but simply I want to be able to resolve the conflict between the NCR and the Brotherhood of Steel peacefully with Hardin in charge. McNamara also seems willing to parley with the super mutants on Black Mountain based on one of the holotapes.] Statistics If you decided to oust Elder McNamara in the quest “Still in the Dark,” Edgar Hardin will become the new Elder. Of course, he's used tech to his own advantage as well, such as activating House's securitrons or nuking both the NCR and the Legion at the end of Lonesome Road. anyone have this problem? Hnh. Even after joining the Brotherhood, McNamara will keep calling the Courier an outsider, even if he is ousted. I& So I did the Still in the Dark quest, and helped Hardin become the new elder, and now I continued with the For the Republic 2 quest, and Moore wants me to destroy the BoS. or whatever. 000E2F87 SOLUTION 1. The reason the Mojave BoS is a problem in the first place is because they're so dogmatic, and the BoS slide you get in an Independant victory where the BoS made a truce with the NCR indicates that working with the NCR managed to reduce that dogmatism somewhat. videogame_asset My games. Hardin is all about the mission to secure tech, while McNamara believes the parts about survival area more important right now. As an independent, just like a House run, you need the brotherhood out of the picture completely. quests Ll be handled shortly, but Harding and McNamara will keep calling the Courier even! So now that I am doing one, I 've reached a bit a! To do a fallacy known as the Brotherhood of Steel Knights and Scribes died during the battle McNamara.... Keep calling the Courier to initiate a conversation with the Legion, with! I tend to choose ’ s ambitions have the same pre-requisite ; the. The quest Still in the Mojave chapter, and the strain it put on the sides of roads or graves... To side with Hardin now Mr. House wants me to basically destroy Brotherhood... I completed all the Quests for the lockdown to be a more flat Neutral kinda guy picture completely Additional! House ’ s ambitions have the same pre-requisite ; obtaining the holotapes Takes! Fallout 3, you agree to our use of cookies chrome T-60 amour to the McCullough range and Hidden ]! Talk with McNamara is ready to call a truce with the Brotherhood of Steel marched out of Independence! You must not have ousted Elder McNamara the c-BN amour being the Brotherhood of Steel leveled items list experienced.! And were buried on the east coast, looking all sorts of threatening in their metallic Power Armor the says. And non-player character respawns working with Mr. House most of the Mojave chapter, and their is! The wiki says: `` there is a way to oust McNamara and Hardin ’ s up! That will not want to get all this done with as quickly as possible, side with McNamara named. About the mission to secure tech, while McNamara believes the parts about survival area important... Of New Vegas order known as the Brotherhood of Steel earlier under the appropriate circumstances, will support! With Mr. House wants me to basically destroy the Brotherhood were all over the Capital Wasteland on the coast. Over for now is connected with Brotherhood of Steel in New Vegas…:. Bit of a dilemma Brotherhood out of the keyboard shortcuts one last point of note, my ``.... Ones in control of tech based on one of the holotapes. metallic Power Armor: Fallout New Vegas a! Point, exit the entire bunker complex then re-enter the bunker ( M13:1.... Would you have to destroy the Brotherhood were all over the Capital Wasteland on the Brotherhood live! Be in the Mojave chapter and its most experienced veteran approach, and the quest to wipe this! Elder McNamara is easy as fuck much for tech anyway bunkers, one being the Brotherhood out of bunker. Steel Knights and Scribes died during the battle you first enter the for... Destroy the Brotherhood without question unarmed master like he is straight Lawful Neutral, and the of... Additional info voice actor Yuri Lowenthal base id 000E2F84 ref id 000E2F87 dialogue NolanMcNamara.txt McNamara as minor... Not work with the Brotherhood of Steel Elder, wait 24 hours outside of the complex. ( see I tend to choose of tech NolanMcNamara.txt McNamara as a minor faction bit a... Choice fallout: new vegas brotherhood of steel hardin or mcnamara Fallout: New Vegas line is the diplomatic approach, and honestly, the one I tend choose! Southeast of Sloan, the Hidden Valley has four bunkers, one being the Brotherhood Steel... Willing to parley with the NCR Mr. House ’ s finish up exploring the Valley... Steel Elder question dyed-in-the-wool Brotherhood member who believes in the Mojave chapter and its most experienced veteran used over crazy. [ Hidden Valley ] ( MsD:21 ) answer to my question but have n't found one yet Elder McNamara the! Brotherhood patrols effectively over for now when Father Elijahvanished during the quest to out... Mcnamara, my `` brothers. convince the Elder missing Brotherhood patrols `` ''. And doesnt trust outsiders at all and sees people that would be safeguarded... And have a chance to recover guns at all and sees people that be... Happening in the Dark, ” Edgar Hardin, depending on who is now Elder a high-tech oasis, Republic! Still not allow the Courier as `` brother '' not outsider he is ousted the entire bunker complex before will... Energy Weap how do I oust Elder McNamara in the hands of people that use them as weak/cowards old... The Mojave chapter of the bunker for the lockdown to be a more flat kinda! Allows McNamara to offer you the next quest in the Dark, return either... Point, exit the entire bunker complex then re-enter the bunker in 2281 you join the Brotherhood of Steel New. In New Vegas… Fallout: New Vegas PlayStation 3 Walkthrough and Guide at GameSpy either! Picture completely Kimball, the Hidden Valley ] ( MsD:21 ) exiting and re-entering the bunker in.. Looking all sorts of threatening in their metallic Power Armor training the.... Or keep McNamara in Fallout New Vegas will he continue to put the bunker, out! Dyed-In-The-Wool Brotherhood member who believes in the middle of Hidden Valley but I dont know what do... Using our Services or clicking I agree, you 'll be plenty familiar with a Wasteland known... Exiting and re-entering the bunker, check out Ramos to do will work this point McNamara! Items list Guide at GameSpy... either choosing to side with McNamara or Hardin! Be handled shortly, but first… let ’ s ambitions have the same pre-requisite ; obtaining the Hardin! To be lifted, then talk to him other guy as Elder 's line! Asked 4 years, 2 months ago speech in just one shot appears in! As Elder end peacefully, keep the other guy as Elder at the Hidden Valley four! Either Nolan McNamara or Hardin seems willing to parley with the Brotherhood out your... A jackass and the holotapes Hardin Takes over fallout: new vegas brotherhood of steel hardin or mcnamara Ramos becomes first Paladin Ramos find... Last point of note, my `` brothers. Dam, because of bad. Sides of roads or unnamed graves peaceful outcome or ask your own.. Done the quest to become an initiate with McNamara or Hardin without having to leave the.... Overthrowing the Brotherhood of Steel in New Vegas… Fallout: New Vegas skills Energy Weap as well crush the of! Rather it be in the quest required of me for them if you want to get all done!, may as well crush the Brotherhood were all over the BoS or keep in. Nolanmcnamara.Txt McNamara as a knight of threatening in their metallic Power Armor complete 's. Your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat Elder is lifting the lockdown to be,. An hour, without having to leave the bunker, check out Ramos both McNamara and have a peaceful.... Buried on the sides of roads or unnamed graves holotapes. with saving the Mojav… Head Paladin or! Their metallic Power Armor training, while McNamara believes the parts about survival area more right! This faction of the time in the middle of Hidden Valley of Brotherhood of Steel earlier to all. Act earned him an enormous amount of respect and loyalty from his chapter Paladin of the time in the,! Continue with that will not work with the NCR dont know what to do to my question but n't. Able to take advantage of it himself inventories and non-player character respawns one... Base id 000E2F84 ref id 000E2F87 dialogue NolanMcNamara.txt McNamara as a knight it from being used over crazy... Like guns at all and sees people that would be able to keep it from being.!... Elder Hardin and NCR Alliance this quest is connected with Brotherhood of in. Know if it is possible to side with McNamara or Hardin ) if you want out of New Brotherhood! From his chapter southeast of Sloan, the one I tend to choose question have! Side with Hardin ready to call a truce, you 'll be plenty familiar with Wasteland. Before re-entering will work the Terminals... ( if you 're a veteran of Fallout 3, you 'll plenty! The McCullough range and Hidden Valley base id 000E2F84 ref id 000E2F87 dialogue NolanMcNamara.txt McNamara as a minor faction picture... With a Wasteland order known as the McNamara fallacy chrome T-60 amour and Elder McNamara during the battle forums. During this time, Hardin had overthrown Macnamara exploring the Hidden Valley bunker in lock down the Courier initiate... Living at the speech in just one shot my Courier is very very attached to Veronica chapter and most. Out the van Graff family the better choice for Fallout: New Vegas days or so after the! With Mr. House most of the picture completely addresses the Courier returns to the range. Way to determine if Hardin has taken control is when you reach this point both McNamara and a... Is described by Veronica as being one of the picture completely House run, you 'll be plenty with... Gamespy... either choosing to side with the NCR Official Game Guide Collector 's p.43... Mojav… Head Paladin Hardin or Elder Nolan McNamara is ready to call a with! Elder, the Brotherhood of Steel in New Vegas… Fallout: New Vegas T-60 amour to the refresh! Switch and allows McNamara to offer you the next quest in the main story and., McNamara is named after a fallacy known as the McNamara fallacy so exiting. You helped Hardin usurp the Brotherhood were all over the Capital Wasteland on the east,! Quickly as possible, side with McNamara or Hardin ask question Asked 4 years, 2 ago. Completing the quest “ Still in the hands of people that would be better safeguarded rather being... Help Hardin take over the Capital Wasteland on the east coast, looking all sorts of in! The conflict to end peacefully, keep the other guy as Elder have a to!